Reviewed by: ewaffle
Summary: Only worth seeing if you are mad about one of the actresses
Depending on how you feel about such things, this movie is either a) tasteless; b) politically incorrect or c) transgressiveespecially by 2005 American conventions. Since it was made for a local audience 17 years ago the point can be made that we cant really judge it from a very different time and placethat to do so would be anachronistic, imposing standards that didnt exist then.
Reviewer Score: 4
However...How to Pick Girls Up is an only occasionally funny comedy. Its view of women is not untypical of mainstream movies, whether made in Hollywood, Western Europe or Hong Kong. It says that women must have men in order to exist. In the Wong Jing universe a woman might be intelligent, rich, successful, talented and drop dead gorgeous. But until she hooks up with a guyeven if the guy is stupid, poor, ineffectual, crude and uglyshe has to keep looking. And a morally reprehensible guy, like the Love Pain Killer, is still better than none at all.
The only reason to see this movie is the actresses. I rented it because it has two of my favoritesMaggie Cheung and Chingmy Yau. Since I would gladly crawl across a field of broken glass in order to touch the hem of Maggie Cheungs garment (or something like that) sitting through ninety minutes of a Wong Jing masterpiece in order to see her was not much to ask. How to Pick Girls Up was released in 1988a year that saw ELEVEN movies with the Maggster hit the screens. It was Chingmy Yaus second movie.
In watching the early work of favorite artists it is difficult not to see it from the point of view of what they have becomeeven in such lightweight fare. There is a sense of inevitability that only exists when one is looking back. Obviously Maggie Cheung had a lot of fans in 1988but none of them could say that years later she would be one of the most respected motion picture actresses in the world, a person who drops into Berlin, Venice and Cannes in order to pick up a Best Actress award one year and to sit on the jury the next. After seeing In the Mood for Love, Comrades, Almost a Love Story, Clean, Irma Vep, Centre Stage and several other films it is tempting to look this one and say that the kernel of her later success was apparent in her worktempting but wrong, of course.
She has a couple of excellent entrances and some decent linesnot only, for example was the father of her one year old son killed in a fight, so were many of her other ex-boyfriendsa bit later we find that he was killed in a car accident. Maggie is a whirlwind of energy, easily dominating the lovesick Wilson Lam. We tend to empathize with himshe is gorgeous and full of life and her quasi-underworld background gives her an additional edge. But mainly Maggie hits her mark and says her lines. She plays a one dimensional character, which is the way her character (and everyone else) is written.
The same is essentially true of Chingmy Yau who plays Beibei. One cant make the leap from this movie to, for example, Naked Killerher insanely sexy overbite wasnt even deployed in How to Pick Girls Up.
The other actresses are also as good as they are allowed to be by the material. Elizabeth Lee is Hong the bat wielding friend of Beibei. It is hard to believe that Maggies character would fall for the decent but painfully shy He Matong (Wilson Lam) or that successful TV actress Beibei would be interested in Xin Jeijinjgessentially Wong Jing playing Wong Jing. But it is impossible to think that Fei Changfan (Stanley Fong) would get a second glance from Hong after his disgusting attempts to gain her favor.
At least when Ellen Chan as Yuki seems to fall for the Love Pain Killer himself it is clear that there is something happening under the surfaceshe must have an ulterior motive. The problem is that the other women dontthey are just looking for guys to hang on to and it is obvious that just about any guy will do.
I cant imagine seeing this movie in a theaterit is what the fast forward button was made for.
Recommended only for those (like me) who will see anything with a favorite actress.
Reviewed by: nsbr1
A fairly anemic romantic comedy, but with an excellent cast of Maggie Cheung, Chingmy Yau, Sandra Ng, Eric Tsang, Stanley Fung and Wong Jing.
The main pleasure of viewing this film is getting to see both Maggie and Chingmy in one of their early films. Both look great with Maggie still having
that adorable crooked toothed grin and Chingmy also looking very fresh, but somehow different then in her later films. The plot revolves around three men getting advice from Eric on how to woo women. A few funny scenes with Maggie make the film a worthwhile look for her fans.