Data addition: DUMPLINGS

[ciakmull]

Dumplings (2004)

[calros]

Added alias, prod. company, prod., presenter, writer, phot., music, editor, art dir., costumes, 7 actors more and their roles.

[bkasten]

Actually, the primary English title of this movie should be changed. It's wrong. I don't have the DVD, but I believe it is exactly:

Three...Extremes: Dumplings

[ciakmull]

I think the correct primary english title should be just Dumplings. The title Three... Extremes: Dumplings refers to another movie composed by three shorts. The Dumplings episode in Three... Extremes and the Dumplings released by itself on dvd are quite different, the first lasts just 30 minutes while the latter is 90 minutes long and contains different footage. I think it's the same with the first Three movie, co-directed by three asian directors. It's a bit different from Peter Chan's Three: Going Home. Probably we should split all the entries for a total of four entries: 1) Three; 2) Three: Going Home; 3) Three... Extremes; 4) Dumplings. Anyone agrees?

[bkasten]

I think the correct primary english title should be just Dumplings. The title Three... Extremes: Dumplings refers to another movie composed by three shorts. The Dumplings episode in Three... Extremes and the Dumplings released by itself on dvd are quite different, the first lasts just 30 minutes while the latter is 90 minutes long and contains different footage. I think it's the same with the first Three movie, co-directed by three asian directors. It's a bit different from Peter Chan's Three: Going Home. Probably we should split all the entries for a total of four entries: 1) Three; 2) Three: Going Home; 3) Three... Extremes; 4) Dumplings. Anyone agrees?

I, for one, agree.

But in any case, what is there now is completely incorrect.

[calros]

If I understand it well, Mr. Ciakmull wants to add :

the title "Three: Going Home" as alias to the film "Three" (2002)

the title "Three... Extremes" as alias to the film "Three Extreme: Dumplings" (2004) and remove this last title and put "Dumplings" as main title.

Did I get it well?

[bkasten]

If I understand it well, Mr. Ciakmull wants to add :

the title "Three: Going Home" as alias to the film "Three" (2002)

the title "Three... Extremes" as alias to the film "Three Extreme: Dumplings" (2004) and remove this last title and put "Dumplings" as main title.

Did I get it well?

I think that is correct.

[ciakmull]

I'm suggesting to split all the Three's movies in four different entries:

1) Three (2002) - Co-directed by Nonzee Nimibutr, Peter Chan and Kim Jee Won.

2) Three: Going Home (2002) - Directed by Peter Chan (although it's just 60 minutes long, this movie had a separate theatrical release, so it should count as movie by itself).

3) Three... Extremes (2004) - Directed by Miike Takashi, Fruit Chan and Park Chan-wok.

4) Dumplings (title alias: Three... Extremes: Dumplings) (2004) - Directed by Fruit Chan.

[calros]

OK, you are the expert!!!!

[ciakmull]

Thank you. I'll post the screenshots of the other three movies asap.