Page 1 of 1

Merge Sap Ng-Long and Jeng Sap Ng Long ?

PostPosted: Wed Oct 01, 2014 8:40 am
by heinz Germany

Re: Merge Sap Ng-Long and Jeng Sap Ng Long ?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 04, 2014 9:24 am
by calros
According to HKFA "Song of Merry Music" was written/planned by Sap Ng-Long, but the editor who added that credit, wrote "Jeng Sap Ng Long" instead. Why?
If nobody stops me in 15 days I will merge them.

Re: Merge Sap Ng-Long and Jeng Sap Ng Long ?

PostPosted: Sat Oct 04, 2014 2:58 pm
by dleedlee
calros wrote:According to HKFA "Song of Merry Music" was written/planned by Sap Ng-Long, but the editor who added that credit, wrote "Jeng Sap Ng Long" instead. Why?
If nobody stops me in 15 days I will merge them.


Funny, I saw the same thing but I drew a different conclusion: The id in our db is very low, #3448 (point of ref., today #67788 added), so it is likely part of the original db load years ago, not a manual editor entry. ???? is found under HKFA search, so it wasn't created out of thin air. My presumption is that once upon a time there were separate entries in HKFA. Over the years, HKFA has made corrections/updates and additions over time - just like us. Sometimes they make errors, too. I have even seen differences in credits between Eng/Chi version entries.

Just an alternative perspective.

Re: Merge Sap Ng-Long and Jeng Sap Ng Long ?

PostPosted: Tue Nov 04, 2014 3:56 pm
by calros
merged

???
Sap Ng-Long

Filmography (1965-1966)

Writer (4 films)
Country Girl Goes to Town (1965)
A Modern Monkey King (1965)
Back-up Bride (1966)
Funny Girl Captures a Thief (1966)

and

????
Jeng Sap Ng Long

Filmography (1967)

Planning (1 film)
Song of Happiness (1967)
Writer (1 film)
Song of Happiness (1967)