Invincible Iron Palm: two other entrys?

[Michael Kistner]

Maybe a old matter:

That three movies look like the same movie:

http://hkmdb.com/db/movies/view.mhtml?i ... ay_set=eng

http://hkmdb.com/db/movies/view.mhtml?i ... ay_set=eng

http://hkmdb.com/db/movies/view.mhtml?i ... ay_set=eng

Always the same cast and the same director.

Someone has a opinion? Can we merge the three movies?

[calros]

Yes, this is an old topic. We are waiting to Mr. Leecoo confirm if they are the same movie with his VHS copy.

http://hkmdb.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=47096

[Michael Kistner]

Nothing has happened and I still think the three movies are the same.

It looks this time very obvious.

[calros]

I think "36 Tan Tui" was added by Mr. STSH. you should send him a PM.

[STSH]

The image for 36 Tan Tui is from a list on Cyndi Jones' Alan Tang fansite.
As far as I recall, the list is one of Alan's personal recollections of the movies he has made.
Over the years of cross-checking since I added the material from that list, I have found a number of the entries confused and less than reliable.

So I have no objection to merging this entry.

Pity we no longer get notifications of messages. The only reason I logged on today was to rate
Out Of Inferno, which I saw at the movies yesterday

[Michael Kistner]

If no one objects I merge the movies soon.

Thank you.

[Michael Kistner]

Merged

?????
Gui Shou Long Hu Men (1972)
Alias : ?????
Country: Taiwan
Director
Chu Mu
Script
Chu Mu
Cast
Charlie Chin Chiang-Lin
Alan Tang Kwong-Wing
Chen Kuan-Tai
Pai Ying (2)
Ingrid Hu Yin-Yin
Cheung Kei (1)
Tony Liu Jun-Guk

and

?????
36 Tan Tui (1972)
Mandarin Title: San Shi Liu Dan Tui
Cantonese Title: Sam Sap Luk Tan Tui
Literal Translation: 36 Snap Kicks
Country: Taiwan
Director
Chu Mu
Cast
Charlie Chin Chiang-Lin
Pai Ying (2)
Alan Tang Kwong-Wing
Ingrid Hu Yin-Yin
Cheung Kei (1)

with

?????
The Invincible Iron Palm (1971)
Country: Hong Kong
Genre: Martial Arts
Release Date: 12/29/1971

Director
Chu Mu
Script
Hoi Ling

Action Director
Chan Siu-Pang
Cast
Alan Tang Kwong-Wing
Charlie Chin Chiang-Lin
Ingrid Hu Yin-Yin
Tony Liu Jun-Guk
Pai Ying (2)
Cheung Kei (1)
Chu Mu
Chiang Nan (1)
Wong Sam (1)
Woo Kei
Lee Man-Tai
Ma Chien-Tang
Leung Yui
Sai Gwa-Pau
Jason Pai Piao
Chen Kuan-Tai
Hao Li-Jen
Eddy Ko Hung
Yeung Wai (1)
Chow Siu-Loi
Yi Fung
Ang Saan
Tung Ping
Chan Seng-Tong
Law Kei (1)
Chu Ming (2)
Chu Tou
Chai Lam
Ling Hon (1)
Chu Hsi (2)
Ting Hon ... Thug
Cliff Lok ... extra
Hon Yee-Sang ... extra
Chan Lau (2) ... extra
Wu Por (1) ... extra
Unknown SB-Actor(25) ... extra
Chow Kong (1) ... extra
Tong Kam-Tong ... extra
Gam Tin-Chue ... extra
Yue Tau-Wan ... extra

Production Company
San Yang Film Co.

Cinematographer
Ngai Hoi-Fung

Production Manager
To Mui-Hing

Sound Recordist
Chang Hua

Art Director
Law Man (4)

Editor
Vincent Leung Wing-Chan

Costume Designer
Lee Chung-Chun (2)

Planning
Wang Zhao-Xi

Presenter
San Yang Brothers

Makeup
Tu Yung-Wei

Assistant Director
Yi Fung

Composer
Joseph Koo Ka-Fai

I ignored questionable English titles (= translations of the alternate chinese titles). Writer Hoi Ling could be an alias for Zhu Mu.

Result:

http://hkmdb.com/db/movies/view.mhtml?i ... ay_set=eng